Proposition 33’s Defeat and What It Means for San Diego’s Real Estate Market
The California real estate market dodged a significant shift last year, and the ripple effects are still shaping our local landscape in San Diego. A recent article from the California Association of Realtors® (C.A.R.) highlights their award-winning “No on Proposition 33” direct mail campaign, which earned a prestigious 2025 Pollie Award for its role in defeating Proposition 33. As a San Diego real estate broker, I’m diving into what this means for our market, backed by data and practical advice to help buyers and sellers navigate today’s opportunities. Read on to stay informed and make smarter real estate decisions!
Summary of the Article
The C.A.R.’s “No on Proposition 33” campaign, titled “Flipping the Housing Narrative on Rent Control,” was a powerhouse effort that reached over 12.8 million voters across California. Recognized with a Gold Prize in the 2025 Pollie Awards by the American Association of Political Consultants (AAPC), the campaign secured a resounding “No” vote against Proposition 33 in every county. Proposition 33 aimed to repeal the Costa-Hawkins Rental Housing Act, which currently limits the extent of rent control measures cities can impose. Had it passed, local governments could have enacted strict rent controls without voter approval, potentially disrupting California’s rental and housing markets. You can read the full article here.
Implications for the San Diego Real Estate Market
The defeat of Proposition 33 is a win for market stability in San Diego, where our real estate ecosystem thrives on balance between renters, landlords, and homeowners. Here’s why this matters:
Preservation of Rental Market Incentives: The Costa-Hawkins Act ensures that landlords can adjust rents to market rates when tenants move out and exempts newer properties (built after 1995) from rent control. Without this, strict rent caps could discourage property owners from renting or maintaining units, reducing rental supply. In San Diego, where the rental vacancy rate is already tight at 3.8% (per 2024 CBRE data), this could have exacerbated competition for rentals, driving prices higher paradoxically.
Encouragement for New Construction: San Diego’s housing shortage—estimated at 88,000 units by the San Diego Association of Governments (SANDAG)—requires robust development. Proposition 33’s potential to impose rent controls on new buildings could have deterred developers, slowing construction. The defeat supports continued investment in multifamily projects, like the 1,200 units planned in downtown San Diego by 2027 (per City of San Diego reports).
Property Value Stability: Rent control expansions often lead to lower property values, as investors perceive reduced income potential. San Diego’s median home price, currently $975,000 (per California Regional MLS, May 2025), could have faced downward pressure, impacting homeowners’ equity. The “No” vote helps maintain confidence in our market’s long-term value.
Expert Analysis
While Proposition 33’s defeat is positive, San Diego’s market isn’t without challenges. Rising interest rates (hovering at 6.8% for a 30-year fixed mortgage, per Freddie Mac, June 2025) and affordability concerns continue to temper demand. However, the stability preserved by rejecting Prop 33 creates a predictable environment for investors and homeowners alike. Posts on X reflect bipartisan relief, with users noting that 62% of voters rejected Prop 33, signaling a shared understanding that extreme rent controls could backfire ().
On the flip side, tenant advocates argue that San Diego’s high rents—averaging $2,800 for a two-bedroom apartment (per Zillow, May 2025)—justify stronger protections. While valid, the data suggests rent control alone doesn’t solve affordability. A 2023 UC Berkeley study found that rent control reduced rental supply by 15% in some California cities, pushing prices up for non-controlled units. San Diego’s focus should remain on increasing housing supply through zoning reforms and incentives, as outlined in the city’s 2025 Housing Element plan.
Practical Advice for Buyers and Sellers
For Buyers:
Act Strategically: With inventory low (1.9 months of supply, per San Diego MLS, May 2025), competitive offers are key. Consider fixer-uppers in neighborhoods like North Park or City Heights, where median prices are $850,000, offering entry points below the county average.
Explore Financing Options: Look into FHA loans or down payment assistance programs like the San Diego Housing Commission’s First-Time Homebuyer Program, which can ease affordability hurdles.
Stay Informed: Monitor local zoning changes, as San Diego’s push for density near transit hubs (e.g., Middletown’s redevelopment) could create new buying opportunities.
For Sellers:
Price Competitively: Overpricing can deter buyers in a high-interest-rate market. Work with your agent to align with recent comps, ensuring your home stands out.
Highlight Investment Potential: San Diego’s stable rental market, bolstered by Prop 33’s defeat, appeals to investors. Market your property’s rental income potential, especially in high-demand areas like Pacific Beach.
Stage for Success: Invest in professional staging to showcase your home’s lifestyle appeal, as 82% of buyers say staging helps them visualize living there (per NAR, 2024).
Why This Matters to You
San Diego’s real estate market is dynamic, and staying ahead requires trusted insights. The defeat of Proposition 33 underscores the importance of balanced policies that support both renters and property owners. Whether you’re buying, selling, or investing, our team at [Your Brokerage Name] is here to guide you with data-driven strategies tailored to San Diego’s unique market.
Share this post with friends or family navigating the market, and the home page for more expert analysis, market updates, and personalized advice. Let’s make your real estate goals a reality!